The Picnic Basket Restaurant - Nashotah, Wisconsin

Nate G.

Stopped in for lunch on my break. Seated right away, I had the Arizona BBQ southwest wrap, Dead ends, and a side of pasta salad. A+ across the board! Great atmosphere, great service (Laura was my server and she was awesome!), and the food was excellent! I've stopped here a few times to get their take and bake pizza's (by the way AMAZING!) and I just had to stop in to try the food. Definitely glad I did and will return to try more! 😁👍

Nicole W.

Wow, was I DISAPPOINTED.
First, we got less than $30 of food, used a coupon for $15 for $30 and still had to pay a full $15 (dispute not buying $30 of actual food- it should be half of what you buy but this isn’t my real issue).
I got the guacamole chicken bacon wrap- WHAT A SCAM. I didn’t read the fine print and realized upon my first bite, that there is NO ACTUAL GUACAMOLE ON THIS WRAP. It’s guacamole mayo- overall, it was very, very bland. Pasta was mid and chips came in a weird, greasy tied bag that made me uncomfortable.
I don’t think I’ll be back. Can’t believe how high the ratings are.

P

Fantastic food! Our go for an amazing sandwich -we love the corn beef!! Warm delicious, juicy and satisfying. One family member is gluten free and the gluten free bread was outstanding! We have gotten the pizza as well in the past - also fabulous. Very busy place but for good reason, can order online for pick up which is ideal, when life gets busy. Highly recommend!!

Skyler D.

I love this place so much! Hands down one of the best sandwich shops you will ever go to. The subs are massive and very reasonably priced. Everything is very fresh and it shows in the quality of the food. The service is top notch, they are always walking around checking on all the tables. The food comes out hot or cold rather quickly. It's a great atmosphere by yourself or with company. They always have some really cool specials so there is always something new to try! Word of advice, always get a rice crispy treat, you'll thank me later.

John M.

Tried the roast beef. I am simply not a fan of cooked and seasoned roast beef. I much prefer it rare and unseasoned. The portions are huge. One 8" sandwich was too much for two small framed people, good thing we shared. We probably would have eaten more if we liked the sandwich.

Elaine J.

The Picnic Basket has the freshest & best sandwiches & wraps around! We often stop by for a quick lunch or a tray of mini sandwiches or wraps for on our pontoon in the summer. Everyone loves them. There is never any left. Wonderful fast, friendly and personable service every time. You won't be disappointed!

Kristine K.

Our first visit to The Picnic Basket was better than expected. The serve subs and sandwiches, but the place itself is cozier than your typical fast food sub shop. Being middle of winter, however, it was chilly inside and we had to leave our coats on throughout the meal. The food was SO good, and the waitress anticipated our needs and was present just the right amount of time. I would highly recommend this place for a casual dinner and get-together.

Update: We've been to the Picnic Basket at least 7 or 8 times since the last review, and happy to say, service and food were of the same quality each visit. We've also had a meal or two there on chilly days, with no recurrence of the cold during the meal, so perhaps there was something off with their heating on our first trip there. I still recommend this place highly, and have passed my recommendations on to friends as well.

Tuddy

Great food and even better customer service. I’ve had a great experience every time I’ve been out there. Nothing like a BLT Marathon sandwich.